Why Are Canadian Craft Breweries Closing — And What It Means for the Ones Still Standing

The locks went on the door of a beloved taproom in your neighbourhood sometime in the last two years. Maybe it was a spot you took friends to when they visited. Maybe it was where you had your first craft beer that actually tasted like something. Maybe you just drove past it on a Tuesday and noticed the windows were dark and the chalkboard menu was gone. You probably thought: what happened?

The answer is complicated. And it has almost nothing to do with the quality of the beer.

Canada's craft brewery count is shrinking for the first time in over a decade, and the reasons behind each closure tell a story about costs, timing, culture, and a beer market that has quietly, persistently been getting smaller every single year. This is not a eulogy. But it is an honest account of what is happening — and what the breweries still standing are doing differently.

The most important number in Canadian beer right now is not how much money breweries are making. It is how much liquid Canadians are drinking. And that number has been falling for eight consecutive years.

In 2023/24, total beer sales by volume in Canada dropped 4.5% to 1.95 billion litres — the steepest single-year decline since Statistics Canada began tracking alcohol sales. Per-capita beer consumption fell 5.2% in the same period. The eighth straight annual decline. Not a blip. A direction.

Here is the confusing part: revenue is up. Regular Canadian beer hit a record $3.1 billion in 2023/24. Breweries charged more per pint, and Canadians paid it. So the headlines read “record revenue” while the floor is actually getting smaller under everyone's feet.

What this means in practice is that bigger breweries — with scale, distribution deals, and marketing budgets — can absorb shrinking volume while growing revenue per litre. Small independent taprooms, which rely on foot traffic and local loyalty rather than national shelf space, feel the volume decline directly in empty stools on a Tuesday night.

When the consumer sees a $9 pint and thinks ‘greedy brewery,’ the reality is often that the margin on that pint is thinner than ever.

— Canadian Craft Brewers Association, 2024 Industry Brief

The conversation about brewery closures tends to focus on the demand side — fewer people drinking, competition from cocktails and cannabis, the “sober curious” generation. That is real. But the supply side is just as brutal, and it gets far less attention.

The Canadian Craft Brewers Association has been direct in its industry communications: small independent brewers are now operating at a significant structural cost disadvantage relative to large-scale national and multinational producers. The CCBA estimates that input costs for small independent brewers are now roughly three times higher than those faced by foreign-owned mainstream multinationals — not because they brew worse, but because they buy less of everything and can't negotiate volume discounts.

Add to this the federal excise duty — a tax on every litre produced — which, despite a 50% cut on the first 15,000 hL secured through CCBA advocacy, left many small breweries seeing that relief entirely absorbed by inflation elsewhere in the cost stack.

So the brewer who opens a beautiful taproom, hires a great team, and makes genuinely excellent beer can still find themselves doing the math at midnight and realising the numbers do not work. It is not incompetence. It is arithmetic.

The “opened too late” problem

A meaningful number of the breweries that have closed in 2024 and 2025 opened during the boom years — 2016 to 2020 — on the assumption that the growth curve would continue. They took on expensive long-term leases in high-traffic neighbourhoods. They built elaborate taprooms with custom millwork and expensive sound systems. They launched with twelve beers on a menu designed to make a statement.

When volume softened, the lease payment did not. The equipment loan did not. The staff roster built for a busy taproom did not shrink easily. And in neighbourhoods where three craft breweries had opened within six blocks of each other, there was not enough local loyalty to go around. The nuance your friends in craft beer circles are too polite to say out loud: many of the breweries that closed were not bad. They were just late, over-leveraged, and under-differentiated.

It would be easy to blame the closure wave on drinkers who abandoned craft beer for canned cocktails or mocktails. The reality is more nuanced and, in some ways, more threatening: consumers have not stopped going out. They have stopped having the same night out.

Canadians are still patriotic about their drinking choices — domestic beer accounts for 88 cents of every beer dollar spent nationally. But beer's share of the overall drinking occasion has been quietly surrendering ground to RTDs (ready-to-drink cocktails), hard seltzers, no-alcohol options, wine, and cannabis. When a group of four goes to a taproom and one orders a sour, one orders a craft lager, one asks for an NA beer, and one has a canned cocktail from the fridge — that is four different drinking occasions in one booth.

None of those individual choices is wrong. But the aggregate effect on a brewery running on thin margins is real. A table that orders four pints and a round of wings has a completely different impact on a small brewery's cash flow than a table that orders two pints, one NA, and a water.

Here is where the story earns its optimism. The breweries that are not just surviving but growing in this environment share something in common that has nothing to do with their beer recipes. They are running their taprooms like community anchors, not like drinks counters. And they are getting creative in ways that a category flush with easy money never had to.

What made Wyrd Bier work was not the weird beers, although those helped. It was that the breweries stopped competing with each other for a fixed pool of local craft beer drinkers and started competing together against the broader question of “what should I do tonight?” A passport that sends you to 19 taprooms is not a beer event — it is an adventure. And adventures beat Netflix on a Saturday.

The deeper lesson is that the breweries growing right now are the ones that understand they are in the hospitality business first, the beverage business second. They are programming their calendars with trivia nights, meet-the-brewer events, local food truck partnerships, vinyl record afternoons, and seasonal tasting experiences. They are training staff to be guides and storytellers, not just pourers.

This is the part of the story that is hard to say while a neighbourhood taproom is still warm in the memory. But it deserves to be said, because it is probably true.

The boom years of Canadian craft brewing — roughly 2010 to 2022 — produced extraordinary things. They changed what Canadians expected beer to taste like. They created thousands of jobs and dozens of genuinely world-class breweries. They made the LCBO shelf more interesting and the local restaurant menu more complex. They also produced, in some cities, a level of over-saturation that was always going to resolve itself eventually. Four craft taprooms within three blocks of each other, all making broadly similar IPAs and pale ales for the same demographic, was not a sustainable ecosystem. It was a gold rush, and gold rushes end.

Continue Reading

Read Next · Part 2 of 3

Beyond the Pint: How Menus Decide Which Canadian Breweries Survive

The gap between a taproom that thrives and one that closes often starts long before a single pint is poured.

Read Next · Part 3 of 3

More Than Beer: Why Smart Breweries Are Expanding the Menu

How NA beer, hop water, and inclusive menus are quietly winning the booking.